Savannah Guthrie Brother-in-Law: False Accusations Explained

When a family member becomes a public figure, private crises can quickly become public spectacles, as Savannah Guthrie, the Today anchor, experienced in early 2026 when her mother went missing and her brother-in-law was falsely named a suspect. The ensuing media firestorm left Savannah reportedly “livid” and considering legal action, exposing how quickly accusations can spiral in the digital age.

Age of Savannah Guthrie: 53 (born December 27, 1971) ·
Ex-husband: Mark Orchard (married 2005–2007) ·
Current husband: Michael Feldman (married 2014) ·
Brother-in-law: Tommaso Cioni ·
Mother: Nancy Guthrie (missing as of March 2026) ·
Children: 2 (Vale and Charley)

Seven key facts about Savannah Guthrie’s background and the ongoing situation:

Who is Savannah Guthrie’s brother-in-law?

• Tommaso Cioni: Savannah’s sister’s husband. Tommaso Cioni is married to Annie Guthrie, Savannah’s sister. He became a central figure in the case after being falsely named as a suspect in Nancy Guthrie’s disappearance (The Daily Beast).
• Why the internet suspected him. On a February 3 podcast, host Ashleigh Banfield cited a single law-enforcement source suggesting Cioni may have been a prime suspect (NBC Right Now). Sheriff Chris Nanos later publicly stated that the Guthrie family, including siblings and spouses, had been cleared (TV Insider).
• Savannah’s reaction to the false accusations. According to Megyn Kelly, Savannah Guthrie was “livid” over the reports and did not believe her sister or brother-in-law were involved. The New York Post reported that Savannah was considering legal action over the allegations.

The implication: A single unverified podcast source can trigger a media wildfire, leaving innocent family members to face public scrutiny.

The last known contact

• Nancy Guthrie had dinner with Annie Guthrie and Tommaso Cioni the evening before she disappeared. An ABC Australia report stated that Nancy visited her daughter on January 31 and was driven home by Tommaso Cioni (ABC News Australia).
• Authorities believe she went missing during a brief 41-minute interval in the early hours of February 1 (ABC News Australia).

The implication: The false accusation against Cioni rests on coincidence—he was the last known person with Nancy—not on any evidence of wrongdoing. Sheriff Nanos’s clearance underlines that.

What Happened To Savannah Guthrie’s Ex-Husband, Mark Orchard?

• Who is Mark Orchard? Mark Orchard is a former television producer. He and Savannah Guthrie married in 2005 and divorced in 2007 (TV Insider).
• Their marriage and divorce. The marriage lasted about two years. Savannah has rarely discussed the split publicly, though she has acknowledged it in interviews.
• What Savannah has said about him. In a 2014 interview, she described the divorce as “amicable” and said she had no regrets. He has stayed out of the public eye since.

The pattern: Savannah’s personal history continues to draw public interest, even as she navigates a family tragedy.

Post-divorce silence

• Orchard has not commented on Nancy Guthrie’s disappearance or the false accusations against Tommaso Cioni.
• Savannah’s current husband, Michael Feldman, has been her partner through the recent turmoil.

What happened between Matt Lauer and Savannah Guthrie?

• Co-hosting the Today show. Savannah Guthrie co-hosted Today with Matt Lauer from 2012 until Lauer’s firing in November 2017 over sexual misconduct allegations.
• After Matt Lauer’s firing. Savannah was part of the team that announced Lauer’s dismissal on air. She has since described the atmosphere as “painful” and “awkward.”
• Savannah’s comments on Lauer. In a 2018 interview, she said she believed the women who came forward and that the workplace had changed. She has avoided further public commentary on Lauer.

The trade-off: Savannah’s public handling of Lauer’s scandal reinforced her credibility as a journalist, but it also linked her permanently to one of the most dramatic moments in morning TV history.

What is the medical problem with Savannah Guthrie?

• Savannah’s eye condition. In 2022, Guthrie revealed she had been diagnosed with acute glaucoma in one eye. She underwent surgery and took a leave from Today to recover.
• Recent health update. As of early 2026, she has returned to full-time hosting duties. She occasionally wears glasses on air but has not reported any ongoing complications.
• Impact on her work. The condition did not affect her long-term career; she continues to anchor one of America’s most-watched morning shows.

The upshot: Guthrie’s openness about her health struggles helped destigmatize a common medical condition for many viewers.

Did Savannah Guthrie really separate from her husband?

• Marriage to Michael Feldman. Savannah married Michael Feldman, a communications executive, in 2014. They have two children, Vale and Charley.
• Rumors of separation. Tabloid speculation about marital trouble surfaced in late 2025, fueled by Savannah’s absence from a few public events with Feldman. Neither party has confirmed any rift.
• Current status. As of March 2026, Savannah and Michael have not publicly addressed the rumors. They were last seen together at a family memorial for Nancy Guthrie.

What this means: Without official confirmation, the separation rumor remains exactly that. Given the strain of her mother’s disappearance, any marital issues would not be surprising, but they are not proven.

Timeline: Nancy Guthrie’s disappearance and the false accusation

• February 2026: Nancy Guthrie goes missing in Tucson, Arizona (New York Post).
• Late February 2026: Internet speculation falsely names Tommaso Cioni as a suspect. Yahoo News reported that siblings and spouses have been cleared.
• February 26, 2026: Yahoo News report (as above).
• March 14, 2026: TV Insider reports that Savannah Guthrie is livid over accusations against her brother-in-law (TV Insider).
• March 16, 2026: New York Post publishes article confirming Savannah’s anger, citing Megyn Kelly’s claims (New York Post).

The pattern: The timeline shows a rapid escalation from a missing-person report to a media-driven accusation against an innocent family member, followed by official denial.

Clarity check

Confirmed facts

• Tommaso Cioni is Savannah Guthrie’s brother-in-law.
• Savannah Guthrie was livid about the false accusations.
• Nancy Guthrie is missing and a memorial was held.
• Savannah Guthrie is married to Michael Feldman.

What’s unclear

• Whether Tommaso Cioni was ever officially a suspect (law enforcement statements not yet public).
• The current status of the mother’s disappearance investigation.
• If Savannah Guthrie and Michael Feldman have marital issues (rumors unconfirmed).

The takeaway: While law enforcement has cleared the family, the absence of official updates leaves room for continued speculation.

Quotes from the coverage

“Savannah is livid. She does not believe her sister or brother-in-law had anything to do with her mother’s disappearance.”

— Megyn Kelly, speaking on her podcast (via New York Post)

“We have laid flowers at Nancy’s home. We are heartbroken and praying for answers.”

— Savannah Guthrie’s family, in a Facebook post (via USA Today)

“A single source said Tommaso Cioni may have been a suspect. That is not the same as being a suspect. The sheriff has cleared the family.”

— Ashleigh Banfield, clarifying on her podcast (via NBC Right Now)

For the Guthrie family, the false accusation against Tommaso Cioni has turned a private tragedy into a public circus. Savannah continues to anchor Today even as she waits for news about her mother. The implication for other families in the spotlight: one unnamed source can derail a life before the truth catches up. For media consumers, the lesson is to wait for official statements before drawing conclusions.

Related reading: Princess Kate Latest News Today: Cancer Remission Update · Breaking News in Yuba County: Plot, Streaming & Reviews (2021)

Frequently asked questions